Welcome to Pine Island Pizza
Pine Island Pizza, located at 5465 Pine Island Rd in Bokeelia, Florida, has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. Under new ownership, the pizzeria has revitalized its menu, offering exceptional New York-style pizza, savory garlic knots, and a variety of delicious dishes that cater to all tastes. Reviewers rave about the friendly service, often provided by local staff, and the inviting atmosphere perfect for families. With convenient parking for boats, it's an ideal stop for those enjoying the island. Pine Island Pizza combines quality food with warm hospitality, making it a must-visit culinary gem on Pine Island.
Pine Island Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Loved the original owners. Was a bit skeptical about the new owners as we had a relationship with the previous owners. The new owners have done a bang up job and added things to the menu that are awesome! I believe the price has come down a bit as well. They do a GREAT job between the counter folks ( usually island local kids, love it), food and service! Best pizza on the island and with much more to offer. You just can't go wrong with this place. Well done!
Great pizza and excellent service! If you haven’t tried it, you should! They have plenty of other options if not looking for pizza. Also a huge plus, you park your truck and boat behind the store.
10 Stars. Best pizza ever, thin New York style is the best type of pizza. Garlic knots are spectacular.
7 lunch special 2 slices of cheese and a soda or for 9 get pepperoni or sausage! Delicious pizza!! Definitely try it out!
Very nice place to eat. The service and customer service here is excellent the pizza is superb and the wings are great. With great home cooking style you can't go wrong. Great place to bring a family. And like I said great service with a great server thank you for your great food and customer service.
Great pizza, meat ball sandwich, and Stromboli! Very clean, kind service. Quick to order and comes out fresh and hot. Will definitely be back.
Excellent food, great mom and pop feel to this place. My son and I grabbed a few slices to hold us over, had a couple bites and looked at the menu while in the car and ended up inside ordering a full pizza. The flavor of freshness popped, I dislike most pizza sauce but this was excellent and a compliment to the rest of the pizza, not over bearing. Needless to say we are happy to have found this place so close. Pete and Marie ( I think) were great super friendly and genuine good people.
What a great little place. The inside wouldn’t be what you expected. Such a quaint little sit down area. Got a cheese pizza with bacon and grilled chicken and it was delicious. Fast service brought right to your table. A from Boston visitors for service and quality!
Location
-
5465 Pine Island Rd, Bokeelia, FL 33922, United States Hotline: +1 239-283-7992
Welcome to Pine Island Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the beautiful surroundings of Bokeelia, Florida. Located at 5465 Pine Island Rd, this charming pizzeria has quickly become a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike. With a phone number easily accessible for orders at +1 239-283-7992, Pine Island Pizza is inviting and convenient.
The heartwarming reviews resonate with patrons eager to share their experiences. Customer Joe Lanktree recalls a time of transition, noting that while he was initially skeptical of the new owners, they exceeded expectations. The expanded menu and remarkable service have firmly established Pine Island Pizza as the top choice for pizza lovers. His favorite? The friendly atmosphere created by local staff, making everyone feel at home.
Another diner, 'FishinBK', highlights the excellent service and variety available at this establishment. Beyond pizza options, Pine Island Pizza offers a range of delectable dishes, ensuring everyone can find something they love. Plus, the convenience of parking your truck and boat behind the store adds an extra layer of ease, especially for those coming from a day out on the water.
No visit to Pine Island Pizza would be complete without trying their thin New York-style pizza, championed by customer Riley. Describing it as "the best pizza ever," Riley's enthusiasm is hard to overstate. Garlic knots, a delightful accompaniment, are also a must-try and perfectly complement any meal.
For those seeking a great deal, Anthony Mejill praises the lunch special—two slices of cheese and a soda for just $7. It's an irresistible offer for pizza aficionados in a hurry or families looking to enjoy a delicious meal without breaking the bank.
Finally, David Shadow notes that the food symbolizes home-cooking goodness, with superb pizza and terrific wings to choose from. The friendly service further enhances the family-friendly environment, making Pine Island Pizza a place where memories can be created over mouthwatering meals.
In summary, Pine Island Pizza offers a delightful fusion of flavors, exceptional service, and a warm atmosphere that makes it stand out among rivals. Whether you're a local or just passing through, stop by and taste what many are calling the best pizza on the island!